Well the Zune is now out and we've been putting it through it's paces. So far, it seems, the device is pretty good, and after some teething troubles with the software we finally seem to be getting somewhere...



Today's round-up of Zune News

Microsoft Chooses Zune's Ad Agency to Promote Zune Phone "Pink" [Microsoft]
(Gizmodo: Thu, 02 Jul) Advertising firm McCann Erickson has won a lucrative advertising contract with Microsoft, beating out CrispiBLAH BLAH BLAH the point is, people—Zune advertising people—are now talking on...


Contests: Enter To Win A Custom Wale-Etched Zune
(Baller Status: Tue, 30 Jun) In anticipation of his upcoming full-length album debut, Attention Deficit , Wale and Zune have produced a limited edition Zune media player -- in blue and red. BallerStatus.com has received one of these custom Zune Wale-etched Zune 8gb devices, not be available for purchase anywhere, and will be giving it away to one of our visitors.


Tegra: In Zune HD, and headed for Windows smartbooks
(WindowsForDevices: Wed, 01 Jul) — Jun. 19, 2009 — Nvidia reportedly says upcoming versions of its ARM-based Tegra will have four and ten times the efficiency of today's chips.


MCS Music sues Microsoft, Yahoo, Real Networks
(MacNN: Thu, 02 Jul) MCS Music America has filed a lawsuit against Real Networks, Yahoo and Microsoft over alleged music copyright infringements earlier this week. The copyright administration company claims the defendants breached copyright on several pieces of music and their artists. MCS represents a large number of other plaintiffs and says streaming music services such as Rhapsody, Zune and Yahoo Music allow ...


Microsoft, Real, & Yahoo All Sued for Music Store Copyright Infringement
(Search Engine Journal: Thu, 02 Jul) On Tuesday, Microsoft, Yahoo, and Real were named in a lawsuit filed by some music publishing companies claiming that each of their online music stores - Zune, Yahoo Music, and Rhapsody - infringe upon their copyrights. If you’re shaking your head and wondering how that is possible, with all the royalties they pay out, you’re not alone. This [...] Check out the SEO Tools guide at Search Engine ...


Xbox Live and Zune Marketplace both acting flaky right now
(Engadget: Sun, 28 Jun) We don't know exactly what's going on, but both Xbox Live and Zune Marketplace are apparently acting up right now -- we've gotten reports that the entire Zune user database is more or less MIA, while Xbox Live seems unable to process purchases reliably. If we had to guess, we'd say that Microsoft's free Thriller video giveaway is causing some pretty massive server strain, but that's just a shot ...


Pirate Bay Sale Signals the Death of an Era
(PC World via Yahoo! News: Wed, 01 Jul) With all the outrage over The Pirate Bay going legit, I think it's time to reconsider the merits of illegally media sharing. The world has changed since Napster introduced peer-to-peer file sharing in 1999, and the culture that made the practice seem necessary has transformed.


New ARM9 dev kit gets Windows CE 6.0 BSP
(WindowsForDevices: Thu, 02 Jul) — Jun. 23, 2009 — Adeneo announced the "full commercial release" of its Windows CE 6.0 BSP (board support package) for Freescale's new i.MX25 product development kit (left).


Our Review of the Zune

The Microsoft Zune
IT'S HERE! This is what all the fuss has been about. Now's the time to find out just what kind of competition Apple's iPod has in store.
   The Zune arrived in a very rugged box which has been superbly designed. It's fabricated out of very strong cardboard and will protect your Zune very well. The outside of the box slides off to present you with a tucked in card that says "Welcome to the social". Lift that up and you'll see your new Zune held in place right in the middle. To either side are small lift up flaps that reveal your USB lead and your earphones. At the top of the box there's another compartment from which you can slide out your installation CD-rom, manuals and a soft pouch for keeping your Zune in pristine condition (until the anticipated Zune covers and holders come out that is).
   You know how it is with your walkman or iPod. When you travel and have to pack up the leads they just have to be bundled wherever you can. With the Zune the earphones and USB lead are supplied in their own rigid plastic container tubes so you can easily store everything away to keep it safe when you travel. All you have to do is keep your small Zune box and the plastic bits etc and you'll always have somewhere extra safe for your Zune.
   Speaking of the earphones, they are actually very neat. One of them has a magnet built in so that they snap together back to back for easy storage. Or you can attach them to the side of your PC when not in use and they'll stay there. Supplied with the earphones are soft, foam covers for added comfort.
   In all, if you have ever owned an iPod and appreciated the attention to detail of the packaging and accessories you'll be equally pleased (if not more so) by what Microsoft have done with the Zune. Contrary to what some commentators have been saying, it definitely doesn't look like a case of Microsoft cobbling together a product in a hurry to try and take on Apple. Absolutely not. If you want to take on Apple's iPod you have to approach the market with a better product - it's the only way.
Hands on The Microsoft Zune
The first thing you notice when you slide the zune out of it's plastic wrapping and peel the protective film from the screen is the feel of the device.
   It feels substantial, with a textured plastic surround to the smooth, low glare screen. The plastic itself is semi translucent, giving the Zune an extra (as they say in France) I don't know what.
   The controls are very simple. There's the central button which is concave and holds your thumb gently in place. With it you can click up, down, left, right and also click the center. These clicks do different things according to what mode the Zune is in. For example, if you are watching a video and have turned the Zune edgeways to view it in widescreen format, the buttons change function to accomodate. As well as the central button there are two others, one either side. The first operates as a 'go back', or 'move up one level' command, while the other serves to operate 'play' and 'pause', as well as turning the Zune on and off.
Hands on The Microsoft Zune
   Elsewhere on the Zune there is a slide switch at the top which lets you lock the Zune's other keys to prevent accidentally operating them by mistake. You know, like turning the Zune on in your pocket and then finding later your battery has run down. Of course, there's the earphone socket right there next to it while, at the bottom, is the docking connecter for your USB lead or other accessories. And that about sums up what the zune is like on the outside, it's look and feel and it's accessories.
   All we would like to add at this point is the one slight negative to all the above. We felt the documentation supplied with the Zune was somewhat lacking. You get a glossy sheet folded into three which basically has three pictures showing a CD being inserted into a laptop, the Zune being connected via USB and the Zune actually connected to the Laptop. There's a sentence describing each while, on the back the eight main key functions also have a sentence each.
   We know, the Zune is an easy device but we'd have liked to have seen some more info in a larger booklet. For example, it might be useful to know in advance that you will have a new program installed to control the Zune, rather than Windows Media Player, and exactly what kind of installation there will be and how long it will take. Also it might be useful to know that by default it will scan your whole disk for files which could leave you hours before you can play with your new toy (unless you change the options from their default during install).
   Still, it's not too important and maybe there'll be more documentation with future models. The important thing for us is that it all worked straight out of the box. In the next section we'll describe what the Zune and accompanying software can do.

Comparing the Zune with the iPod
Comparing the Zune with the iPod
First off, let's compare the Microsoft Zune with the Apple iPod. Pictured on the left are two photos we took of the equivalent device from each manufacturer side by side.
   The relative dimensions etc are exact. As you'll see the Zune is a little larger than the iPod being about 3/8ths of an inch (or a centimeter) taller, and just over a millimeter thicker. They are both almost exactly the same width.
   The iPod is 5.4 ounces (153 grams), while the Zune weighs in at 5.6 ounces (159 grams). So, all told they are pretty similar to each other at first glance. But that's where the similarities end. For a start take a look at that massive screen on the Zune. While the Video iPod is approximately 2 inches by 1.5 inches (3 square inches), the Zune is about 2.5 inches by 2 inches (5 square inches), that's 66% larger than Apple's screen. When you start watching video on the Zune and then go back to an iPod you soon start missing the larger screen size.
   In fact it more than makes up for the really neat touch thumbwheel on the iPod (we assume this is an Apple patent that cannot be used elsewhere), which is the one major thing we miss having when using the Zune. Also, Microsoft have made much better use of the screen. In portrait position you can navigate easily through the various menus and, once you get the hang of it, you'll find that holding the scroll key down turns out to be just as fast as with an iPod, with the bonus that the instant you release the button the scrolling stops. And, as you scroll, the first letter of the section you are in is shown enlarged on the display, so you can quickly jump to the song or artist you are looking for.
   Additionally the color graphics and the way they zoom and fade is an excellent touch. You can also pick from a selection of pre-loaded backgrounds or you can download your own images and use them. And once your Zune has downloaded the album art for your music collection it displays that too, either as small icons next to tracks and albums, or larger on the screen when in play mode.
The brown Zune
   So, what else has the Zune got up its sleeve? Well, let's not forget the built-in radio tuner. As long as you have the earphones connected (to use as an antenna) you also get a high quality FM tuner with your Zune. What's more, as well as auto scanning, you can quickly set your favorite presets and, if a radio station transmits it, you also get to see their RDS (Radio Data System) info, such as the station name, current track playing and so on. Now that may be pretty neat and already another big plus for the Zune compared with the iPod. But possibly the Zune's biggest new introduction is its wireless file sharing.
   With the file sharing you can switch the in-built wi-fi on and 'beam' your favorite tunes to other Zune users. They are then allowed to play that song three times within three days. After that they can choose to purchase the file from the Zune store, or you could just wi-fi it to them again. By default the wi-fi is on so this will impact your battery life by about 10%. But then again, if you turn it off, who knows what goodies you might miss picking up from other Zune users. So it's probably best to only turn it off when you'll be away from other users.
   Incidentally, if someones sends you a song that you really like you don't have to log on straight away to buy it. You can click on a button in your menu to set your Zune to purchase and download the file automatically next time it syncs with your computer. A very handy idea and we are sure the one behind all the wi-fi. Microsoft are likely pretty sure that a lot more music will get sold through the Zune store this way - and we think they're right.
   In the final section of our review we discuss the software that comes with the device and the way it works with the Zune online store.

The Zune Software
This is a screen shot from the Zune software's 'Album Track View'
   Each album is shown with it's album art, and then the tracks for each are listed along with other details you may be used to from using the Microsoft Media Player. If you wish to fit more on the screen you can toggle the view to a simple text view of the tracks.
   In fact, if you are used to using Media Player you'll be pretty much right at home. There are even visualisations you may be used to as well as the ability to play videos directly in the software. What's mostly new, though, is the Zune Marketplace which we will come to shortly.
   The 'Album Art View' shows all the albums you have by their cover. You will see here that only a few of the art graphics have been downloaded. Leave your Zune software running and it will keep fetching more. Scrolling through your music collection in this view is very quick and easy, especially if you remember the covers of all your albums.
Album Art view
   Whether or not you have subscribed to the Zune Marketplace online store you can still view everything that's available there such as the front page, various playlists and the current charts. Not forgetting the facility to browse and search.
   One of the great things we like about the Marketplace is its flexibility. You can either purchase and download individual tracks or, if you prefer, you can purchase a Zune Pass subscription which lets you download as many songs as you like for a flat monthly fee. As long as you maintain your subscription then you can keep the potentially thousands of songs you can download on your Zune.
   But remember, if you select the Pass option and choose to cancel later, your downloaded tunes will also be cancelled (although any purchased individually will remain on your system and playable).
The Zune Marketplace
   We have yet to compare the speed, reliability and depth of the Zune Marketplace with that of the iTunes online store. It certainly appears impressive at first use, but we will report further as we gain more days and weeks experience with the Zune and Zune Marketplace.
   We're still organizing our own music collection and personalizing the review Zune we were sent. We intend to see how much music, video and other data such as photos (did we mention it can store and wi-fi photos?) we can get onto the device. And then we'll start experimenting with charging times and play times under different conditions. Microsoft say you get up to 14 hours audio play time or 4 hours video from a 3-4 hour charge. But that's under optimum conditions. We will find out how it actually performs in the real world.

So now it's time for the $64,000 (probably $1 million in today's money) question.... Is the Zune a better personal media player than the equivalent iPod Video?

In our opinion the Zune is an excellent device but it's not an 'iPod Killer'. It's actually as good as the iPod in some areas, better in others and a little worse in a few others. But for a first release it's definitely a great product.
   Following are the Zune's pros and cons as we see them:

Pros:

  1. It's almost the same dimensions and weight as an iPod yet it has a 66% larger screen
  2. It can store multiple file types and is not limited to Microsoft's proprietary ones
  3. It has a built in FM tuner
  4. It can exchange files with other Zunes wirelessly
  5. The Marketplace online store allows a choice of one-off downloads or a monthly unlimited pass
  6. The battery life appears to be better
  7. The graphics and operating system are much nicer
Cons:
  1. No feather touch thumbwheel
  2. Not a big enough user guide
  3. The Zune software is somewhat quirky
  4. We had to be walked through a patch to get the Zune Marketplace to work. But it does work.
In summary we recommmend that if you have $250 and want to play with a new toy then you'll enjoy the Zune. On the other hand, if you think Microsoft will add even more to the forthcoming version you may wish to wait for a version 1.5 or 2 Zune, in which case the iPod is also still a superb device and well worth buying.

          
Order your Zune or iPod now from amazon.com and get it within a week. These items qualify for free shipping.

© 2006 Robin Nixon News powered by Yahoo! News Thumbnails by Bluga WebThumb